Reviews for Mark Carlson, MD in Rockford, IL

> Report this review

Terrible Doctor. Explained nothing. Has no feeling in his hands. Measured my hip half inch off and gave me drop foot, then dismissed me. I am now walking with a leg brace, permanently damaged my peroneal nerve.

by Joan xxx.xxx.98.159

November 14, 2022

> Report this review

Recently, unbeknownst to me, my 85 year old father visited Mark Carlson for an evaluation of his left knee which has been severely affected by osteoarthritis. My Dad is in no pain.
X-rays were taken which showed degeneration of cartilage and some bone on bone. Mark Carlson recommended knee replacement surgery, which was probably theoretically, a fair evaluation. Although my Dad is in good health for his age, it was a questionable recommendation for an 85 year old man to have major surgery, especially given the pain involved with the surgery, recovery, rehab, and the long list of potential complications.
To be fair, I was not present but from what I can gather, he told my Dad if he didn't have surgery, my Dad would end up in a wheelchair. (my active Dad's worst nightmare).
Mark Carlson was without question unethical when he painted an unrealistic picture to my Dad, misleading my Dad into thinking that it was a simple surgery and that pain and recovery would go smoothly and quickly. "Nothing to worry about". He gave my Dad a false narrative (compared to the standard expectations and recovery time) as to what he should expect as per the pain factor, recovery and rehab timetable, and results. Apparently he did NOT discuss the RISKS involved.
Secondly, Mark Carlson flat out lied to my Dad. My Dad specifically asked him if there were any other options involving knee injections. Carlson told him no. There are numerous knee injection treatments available including stem cell, PRP (Platelet Rich Plasma) and others.
I searched for reviews on Carlson using different sources. He always ranked below the average of other surgeons. Fortunately, my Dad eventually cancelled the scheduled surgery and is pursuing a knee injection.
In addition, I talked to two close friends who had first hand experience with Carlson. One friend told me a horror story regarding her client for whom she was a caregiver. Taking the client to her Carlson appointments, my friend assessed him as a real jerk who had no compassion. Her client developed terrible MRSA infection following the surgery he performed. Carlson then REFUSED to see the patient for follow up visits regarding the very painful and serious infection. Completely UNACCEPTABLE!
The other friend did not like him at all and went elsewhere. Both stated that they would NEVER let Carlson go near them.
It seems quite apparent that Carlson is an unethical hack who is motivated by making money and does NOT have the patient's best interest in mind. Unfortunately, he is not alone when it comes to unscrupulous doctors and surgeons. I may report Carlson to the Illinois Medical Board. Stay away from this guy and spread the word!

by Truth Warrior xxx.xxx.205.171

June 11, 2020

> Report this review

I've been seeing Dr. Carlson for orthopedic issues for nearly 20 years. He AND his staff are GREAT!!!

by Cathi xxx.xxx.180.166

September 17, 2014

> Report this review

Dr. carlson was extremely knowledgeable and my results were womderful. the stuff was friendly.

by Bob xxx.xxx.145.128

September 16, 2014

> Report this review

Great doctor and staff! I will definitely be back for any orthopedic issues I may have in the future!

by Jamie xxx.xxx.98.130

September 16, 2014

> Report this review

Was this doctor's staff friendly?

Yes, they went above and beyond

Were the waiting room chairs comfortable at this doctor's office?

Extremely comfortable; I could have fallen asleep

Did this doctor answer all of your questions?

Every question I had was answered thoroughly

Did you leave the office feeling satisfied with your visit?

Completely!

Was it easy to make an appointment with this provider?

Yes

by Anonymous xxx.xxx.223.102

June 27, 2014

> Report this review

Was this doctor's staff friendly?

Yes

Does this doctor use current and safe equipment?

Yes

Would you recommend this doctor to others?

Yes

Was this doctor friendly?

Yes

Does this provider maintain a professional appearance?

Yes

by Anonymous xxx.xxx.40.37

June 22, 2014

> Report this review

I have been going to this clinic for almost 10 years and have had 4 surgeries done by Mark Carlson. He is really great at what he does and makes sure you have no doubts or questions concerning procedures. I have been in the clinic for several different things over the years and would never think about going anywhere else. Everyone is super friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. Sometimes the waiting time for appointments can be long but that’s how it is at any appointment, emergencies can occur...it just happens. Great place - would not think about going anywhere else for orthopedic care.

by Allison xxx.xxx.194.10

January 08, 2014

> Report this review

Does this provider offer flexible appointment times?

Yes

Does this provider have a good professional reputation within your community?

Yes, they are known for being good at what they do

Are you confident that this provider will continue working with you until a solution is reached?

Yes, I know I can count on them to find a solution

Did this provider seem up-to-date with the current advancements in their field?

Yes

Was there annoying music playing while you waited or during your visit?

No, there was no annoying music

by Anonymous xxx.xxx.87.60

February 28, 2013

> Report this review

Were you able to get answers to simple questions from this provider without scheduling an appointment?

Absolutely! I'm always able to get my questions answered over the phone right away!

by Anonymous xxx.xxx.107.178

January 09, 2013

Mark Carlson, MD

Orthopedic Surgeons

Scott Trenhaile, M.D.

Rockford, IL

Rockford Spine Center

Rockford, IL

Rockford Spine Center

Rockford, IL

Rockford Orthopedic Associates Ltd

Rockford, IL

Consumer Feedback